[LTP] [RFC PATCH 4/4] memcg_stress_test.sh: allocate less than CommitLimit bytes

[Stanislav Kholmanskikh]

On 05/17/2016 03:52 PM, Stanislav Kholmanskikh wrote:
> Hi,
>
> On 05/12/2016 04:42 PM, Cyril Hrubis wrote:
>> Hi!
>>> Given that, (CommitLimit - Committed_AS) with overcommit_memory == 1,
>>> looks to be a suitable formula, since the kernel lets allocate this
>>> amount of memory and there will be some memory for other tasks.
>>
>> I wonder what the original purpose of the test is, it looks to me like
>> the whole point is to attach processes to number of memory cgroups and
>> then stress it by allocating memory while forcing heavy swapping. Hence
>> the $mem_free + $swap_free/2 which is wrong obviously.
>>
>> So for the new formula the CommitLimit seems to be calculated as
>> SWAP + RAM * overcommit_ratio which will default to SWAP + RAM/2 in most
>> of the cases. Wouldn't that cause too much swap trashing in case that you
>> have SWAP == 2 * RAM? Shouldn't be something simple as 0.8 * RAM better
>> for the purpose of the test? Or something as 0.9 * mem_free - 50MB after
>> caches has been dropped?
>
> I'm afraid that const * mem_free couldn't be the best formula, since if
> swap is small we may get an OOM here. At least this is what I get in a
> ldom with 128g memory, and < 1gb swap.
>
> There is an idea. If we set memory.limit_in_bytes of a cgroup to a value
> less than the amount of memory.usage_in_bytes, then activities of
> processes of this cgroup will involve swapping.
>
> So what do you think about this scheme:
>
> mem = RAM * overcommit_ratio - CommitLimit

Sorry, I meant Committed_AS here.